Stakeholder Involvement, Culture and Accountability
in the Blackstone Valley of New England USA: A Work in Progress
Authors: Robert Billington,
Ed. D., Veronica Cadoppi, MBA and Natalie Carter, MA.
Institution: Sustainable Tourism Planning and Development Laboratory –
Blackstone Valley Tourism Council Inc, Pawtucket, Rhode Island, USA.
Robert Billington, Ed. D is the
president and founder of the Blackstone Valley Tourism Council and the
Sustainable Tourism Planning and Development Laboratory based in Pawtucket,
Rhode Island, USA. Natalie Carter, MA and Veronica Cadoppi, MBA are the
tourism planners and developers of the Tourism Development Laboratory.
Abstract
Following its historical rise and
fall, America’s first industrialized polluted landscape garnered federal and
local support to remedy its near destruction. Today, the Blackstone Valley
is a pragmatic example of translating theory into practice.
The Blackstone Valley Tourism
Council, since its inception in 1985, has applied leadership, innovation and
commitment to its mission and innovative sustainable tourism place-making
principles in its work. This dedication to its destination, aligned with
principles from the World Tourism Organization (2004), United Nations
Environmental Programme & World Tourism Organization (2005), and the
Geotourism principles of the National Geographic Society, Center for
Sustainable Destinations (2006), has led the way for the Blackstone Valley
to become a sustainable tourism destination.
The Tourism Council has worked to
preserve and enhance the Valley’s environment, respect the socio-cultural
authenticity of the communities, and provide economic growth to all
stakeholders. Social responsibility from all sectors of the community have
led the Valley to find its direction, follow its vision and share it with
others along the way (Billington & Manheim, 2002). The Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council continues to fulfill the vision of sustainable tourism
through the Sustainable Tourism Planning and Development Laboratory. The
Laboratory’s purpose is to share the Tourism Council’s experience in
developing planned sustainable tourism with local, regional, state,
provincial and worldwide tourism leaders, and community stakeholders seeking
to develop viable and successful destinations.
INTRODUCTION
The Blackstone River Valley is
located in New England, the northeast corner of the United States. It is the
home of over 500,000 people living in twenty-four cities and towns
throughout 454 square-miles of land in the watershed of the Blackstone River
Valley. It is the first industrialized river in the nation, where the
American Industrial Revolution was born and manufacturing expanded to
transform the United States into an industrial world power. Millions of
immigrants came to this Valley in search of their American dream. Yet, after
150 years of economic growth, the Blackstone Valley experienced a brutal
economic and social downturn bringing high unemployment, empty factory
buildings, and a heavily polluted river.
Fortunately, in the 1980’s,
leadership, social responsibility, commitment, and a clear common vision led
to re-employment, a higher quality-of-life, and pride-of-place. Thoughts of
sustainable economic change arose. Billington (1999) noted that “a
Valley-wide systematic regeneration” (p. 74) surfaced in the 1980’s looking
for what the Valley once had had: a robust economy and strong community
values. Assisting with the turnaround, the US Congress recognized the
national significance of the Blackstone Valley by establishing the
Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission (BRVNHCC) in
1986. This Commission was designed to support, protect and celebrate the
Birthplace of America's Industrial Revolution. Likewise, President Clinton
declared the Blackstone River an American Heritage River in 1998. Both the
National Heritage Corridor program and the American Heritage River program
were river-based revitalization initiatives. After almost 40 years of
significant economic, environmental, socio-cultural and historical
degradation, thoughtful tourism development and a new approach to corporate
social responsibility emerged in the Blackstone Valley to transform this
landscape into an appealing place.
The Blackstone Valley today is
working to become a sustainable tourism destination and a role model in
North America (Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor, 2006;
Billington & Manheim, 2002; Billington, 1999). Here is its story, how
leadership and commitment, in local, state, federal governments with
thoughtful corporations transformed the Blackstone River Valley into a
laboratory where successful sustainable tourism practices are implemented
and can be modeled to shape destinations around the world.
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
The Blackstone River Valley takes
a fundamental place in the history of the United States because it is where
the American Industrial Revolution started, changing its landscape and
transforming life in this nation. The 46-mile long Blackstone River flows
north to south, from Worcester, Massachusetts to the top of Narragansett
Bay, in Pawtucket, Rhode Island. The importance of the Blackstone River
arises in its power and energy produced by the 438 feet drop in elevation
and its naturally winding path. The Blackstone attracted over 1,000 working
textile factories and resulted in the construction of dams, water power
structures, canals and locks (Blackstone River Valley National Heritage
Corridor, 2006).
The pristine waters of the
Blackstone River were home for several species of fish, such as Atlantic
salmon, shad, and alewives, coming north from the Narragansett Bay and the
Atlantic Ocean. The Nipmuck, Wampanoag and Narragansett Indians migrated
along the banks of the Blackstone River. Likewise, European settlers arrived
to the Blackstone Valley in 1628, building farms and villages along the
Blackstone River and using its waters for fishing, drinking and basic
gristmills.
Conversely, this small village
scenery altered when Samuel Slater, an English immigrant brought to the
Valley his experience as an apprentice in an English cotton-spinning mill.
Because at that point, most of this new country worked in agriculture, and
textile goods were produced in the home, Slater’s knowledge on waterpower
mechanized spinning became an opportunity for him to develop the textile
industry in America and to make his fortune. Moses Brown, who was also
attracted by the idea of expanding this mechanical technique of
manufacturing in the United States, invited Slater to Pawtucket, as he had
just arrived in New York Harbor as an immigrant seeking an opportunity for
his knowledge. Shortly after going to work for Moses Brown, Slater was able
to reproduce the British cotton spinning, roving and carding machines he had
used as an apprentice in Belper, England, thereby giving birth to the
American Industrial Revolution in 1790.
Simultaneously, Eli Whitney
invented the cotton gin, eliminating the time-consuming dilemma of
handpicking seeds out of cotton. This circumstance, in conjunction with
Slater’s system of labor and manufacturing being used throughout the nation,
generated interest in the cotton industry from the South. Consequently, this
initiated the explosion of the textile industry and economic independence in
the United States, which was the beginning of another revolution in America.
Providence, capital of the State of Rhode Island, is located a few miles
south of Pawtucket, where the first successful cotton-spinning mill in
America was constructed. In the late 18th century, Providence businessmen
expanded their shipping endeavors to include the China Trade, which had a
key role in the industrialization of the Blackstone Valley. Rhode Island’s
ports were also part of the Triangle Trade that commercialized rum for
molasses, and later, on slaves from Africa.
In 1792, Slater constructed the first dam across the Blackstone River to
manage its flow and to power the waterwheels in the spinning machines in the
first cotton mill on the banks of the river. Slater developed what was later
known as the Rhode Island System of manufacturing: construction of villages
for families coming to work in the numerous textile mills built along the
Blackstone River. Corporate responsibility, as understood at that time,
created a way of living never seen before. Families lived in houses built by
the mill owners, attended corporate built churches, make purchases at
company-owned stores, and sent children to Sunday school to keep them
occupied on their only day off. Private enterprises were growing as vehicles
for economic development. The more factories that were built, the more
families came to America to work. This pattern of development in the
Blackstone Valley sustained itself well through the 1940’s. This rapid
expansion eventually turned to economic disinvestments and economic
depression.
While encouraging industrial
growth, the textile industry had severe damaging impacts on the environment
and the villages built along the entire length of the Blackstone River. Over
the following 150 years, private businesses built forty-five additional dams
to power more than 1,000 factories in the Blackstone Valley as they searched
for economic growth and disregarded the long-term sustainability of the
region. The promise of stability attracted immigrants coming from different
parts of the world looking to work in the growing textile mills. This
manufacturing movement expanded from New England to the rest of America,
changing its agricultural based economy and imposing the industrial economy.
In the 1860’s, the need for American men to fight in the Civil War
encouraged the textile industry further. There were plenty of opportunities
for employment in the Blackstone Valley.
In 1848, the Providence to
Worcester Railroad helped both of these cities to be the second and third
largest cities in New England. In the 1930’s, inexpensive but reliable
electrical power and low-cost unorganized labor encouraged factories to
leave the Blackstone Valley and move south, as they sought less expensive
and less complicated ways to manufacture their products. This mass departure
left empty deteriorated mills, a polluted landscape and discouraged
communities.
With a polluted river, as a consequence of 150 years of industrial use, and
a vanishing textile industry the Blackstone Valley was confronted by
increasing unemployment. It had low reputation amongst its neighboring
communities and demoralized residents that were ashamed of their river. By
the 1950’s, the Valley had lost its mission, its identity and its vision
(Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor, 2006; Billington &
Manheim, 2002).
In keeping with traditionally
understood business protocol, corporate enterprises do not broadly accept
and commit to social and environmental objectives (Henderson, 2005). This
self-centered corporate behavior was one of the main contributors to the
deterioration of the Blackstone River Valley. As remedy and in order to
achieve sustainable development, through economic dimensions, and
socio-cultural and environmental aspects, there was an imperative need for
corporations to voluntarily become responsible for all stakeholders involved
in their operations (customers, employees, and investors). Moreover, these
corporations need to focus on improving the quality of life of local
residents and visitors (Dodds & Joppe, 2005; Rodwell, 2006; Fraser, 2005;
Henderson; 2005).
REVITALIZATION AND
SUSTAINABILITY
The Blackstone Valley was tired,
abused and depleted. It needed a way out of high unemployment, abandoned
mills, and a deteriorating quality of life. No promotional map developed by
either the state of Massachusetts or Rhode Island included the Blackstone
Valley as a destination. Public policy makers were indifferent to the
difficulties the Valley was enduring. In response, leadership and corporate
social responsibility were a priority subsequently emerging from within the
ailing community.
Surprisingly, as of the 1970’s,
thoughts of sustainable development began to emerge. Project ZAP a locally
based community initiative, turned out 10,000 residents to begin the clean
up of the Blackstone River. In addition, other state and federal
environmental initiatives such as Earth Day, the creation of the US
Environmental Protection Agency, and the establishment of the US Clean Water
Act emerged, to begin the regeneration of the Blackstone River Valley.
Following these efforts, public officials representing the state of Rhode
Island were asked to analyze the creation of a linear park along the river’s
banks in the 1980’s. Because the Blackstone River flowed through
Massachusetts and Rhode Island, this project required bi-state
collaboration: Rhode Island and Massachusetts would have to jointly clean up
the river and subsequently consider developing public recreational land
along the banks of the Blackstone River to insure its restoration for future
generations. In view of this, and in recognition of the historical
significance of the area as the “Birthplace of the Industrial Revolution”,
Congress established the National Heritage Corridor as a unit of the
National Park Service to manage the cultural, historical and natural
resources available to the Blackstone River Valley in 1986. According to
Rypkema (2006), economic development can be shaped in many ways, such as
industrial employment, job security and waterfront development. Yet,
historic preservation and downtown revitalization are the only two ways to
achieve economic and community development concurrently. Therefore, the
Blackstone Valley was to be preserved to tell its story to the world.
As the Valley embraced 24
communities in over 400,000 acres of land, where 500,000 residents lived and
work, the National Park Service suggested that the Blackstone River Valley
should be preserved and interpreted using a unique type of historic and land
preservation system to America. It created the Blackstone River Valley
National Heritage Corridor. Through this mechanism, the National Park
Service would work collaboratively with both states and their communities
but it would not own or manage land or buildings. Therefore, redevelopment
and restoration projects would have to be managed by state, city or private
entities, with the National Park Service providing leadership, technical
assistance, financial support and distinction to the region.
Provisions of The Blackstone River
Valley National Heritage Corridor Act, signed by President Regan in 1986,
continue today. The vital characteristic of the new Act provides that a
top-down management framework from the federal government is prohibited.
Instead, the Act is based on two principles: leadership from above and
leadership from below. Presently, this principle has more strength than ever
(Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor, 2006; Billington &
Manheim, 2002).
This federal legislative Act was
instrumental in helping local leaders of the Blackstone Valley to facilitate
preservation and protection of the lands along the banks of the river and to
obtain resources to encourage economic development, while maintaining and
enhancing the character of the Valley: its environment, culture, aesthetics,
heritage, and the well-being of its residents. These are the principles of
the National Geographic Society and the United Nations World Tourism
Organization (National Geographic Society, 2006; World Tourism Organization,
2004). This new kind of legislation in the United States assisted two states
and 24 cities and towns to work together towards a common planning
mechanism, with the technical support, and some financial assistance from
the National Park Service.
The US Department of Interior
appointed a nineteen-person Commission to supervise and direct this
partnership. The Commission’s responsibilities are to (1) operate within the
community; (2) improve the quality of the river; (3) preserve the history of
the Valley; (4) support the diverse cultures and traditions; (5) develop
interpretative programs about the Valley and; (6) integrate and encourage
quality economic development. Regeneration was based on the community
needing to work together and corporations recognizing and managing their
social responsibility (Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor,
2006; Billington & Manheim, 2002; Schultz, 2001).
PLACE MAKING: A TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY
Place making in the Blackstone
Valley began with the state of Rhode Island designating the Blackstone
Valley Tourism Council to be its regional tourism development agency for the
Northern Rhode Island Tourism District in 1986. This non-profit organization
was responsible for developing tourism in the communities of Pawtucket,
Central Falls, Woonsocket, Cumberland, Lincoln, Smithfield, North
Smithfield, Glocester and Burrillville. Large-scale comprehensive planning
started in 1988 with the creation of the Blackstone River Valley National
Heritage Corridor Commission to achieve the objectives of the National
Heritage Corridor Act created in Congress in 1986. These objectives embraced
river revitalization, public education, land-management planning, historic
and heritage preservation, environmental protection, and respect for the
socio-cultural authenticity of the local communities (Billington, 2004). The
Heritage Corridor adopted it in its planning tourism development as a tool
to accomplish its objectives efficiently and reinvigorate the Valley’s
purpose, identity and direction.
The first step towards
transforming the Valley to a visitor destination was to create a framework
to encourage and promote responsible practices among corporations, visitors
and communities. The Corridor Commission encouraged residents and businesses
to act responsibly and to prioritize a long-term return-on- investment
instead of short-term economic benefits, which could support harmful and
wasteful land use. Building a sense of social responsibility among residents
was essential in order to regenerate the Valley. The community needed to
understand that the Blackstone River could be reborn. America’s first
contaminated river could be cleaned. Since the 1970’s, with the Valley's
original clean-up Project ZAP, several local, state and national initiatives
have been successful in the regeneration of the Blackstone.
Through the years ten’s of
thousands of automobile tires have been taken removed from the river and
estimates indicate that it will take ten more years to clean up the river to
a safe level for human contact. Community cleanup efforts continue to take
place today (Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor, 2006;
Billington & Manheim, 2002; Billington, 2004).
In 1992, the Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council created a regional comprehensive tourism development plan
for Rhode Island’s Blackstone Valley, which was consistent with other plans
for economic, industrial, and Main Street development through out the
Blackstone Valley. This plan promoted synchronized Valley-wide economic
development, while preserving its important industrial heritage,
factory-rich landscapes, socio-cultural diversity, and enhancing a highly
degraded environment (Billington, 2004). According to the Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council (1992), the plan pointed the direction for public and
private sectors to take creative actions and to advocate Valley tourism
strategists to “think regionally and act locally” (p. 7). This plan was also
the basis for tourism planning in the Massachusetts side of the Valley and
ultimately, it became the foundation for the development of a joint tourism
strategic plan and program. This comprehensive long-term plan was key in the
task of place making by engaging the government, sector, the non-profit
sector and the commercial sectors in making the Blackstone Valley a viable,
sustainable visitor destination.
The 1992 tourism plan for the
Blackstone Valley encouraged sustainable tourism principles in which to
build visitor destination. Principles such as the recognition and promotion
of the Valley’s rich cultural resources based in its many ethnicities;
preservation its historic structures, the reclamation of a polluted river
and landscape; the telling of the authentic Blackstone Valley story, the
selection of appropriate markets; the improvement in visitor satisfaction,
robust public involvement in planning and development, using food, music and
celebrations as a way to bring visitors to the Blackstone Valley, strong
involved community, enhancement of visitor appeal of the Valley. The first
Cultural Heritage and Land Use Plan developed by the National Heritage
Corridor Commission included a tourism development component. This component
linked to the tourism development plan written by the Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council.
Both organizations had tourism
development as a community redevelopment strategy. These efforts were joined
to form the Blackstone Valley Tourism Collaborative Strategic planning group
that also included the Blackstone Valley Chamber of Commerce Tourism
Committee.
The Blackstone Valley Tourism Comprehensive was developed with public,
professional, commercial, non-profit and government input over a two-year
period. Its objectives were to look at landscape, historic preservation, and
visitor satisfaction, environmental, recreational, commercial and cultural
changes that were necessary to improve the tourism destination for the
Blackstone River Valley. Its mission was to make a “whole place” of the
tired, industrialized Valley, and to transform it into a great place to
live, do business and interesting place to visit.
NEW INVESTMENTS AND NEW WAYS OF
THINKING
The federal government, through
the National Park Service, assists the Blackstone Valley with approximately
$1,000,000 each year. This investment through the Heritage Corridor to
develop programs to clean the river and promote tourism, build heritage
museums, restore theatres, construct a bike path, and develop a river-access
system, has encouraged regeneration since its inception. These projects
attracted at least $2,000,000 per year in private, city and state funding to
accomplish the overall regeneration plan. Artists and small business owners
started to find the Blackstone Valley an appealing place to settle
(Billington, 2004; Billington & Manheim, 2002). Live/work spaces for
artists, created in old textile mills, are continually being added to meet
demand. Young designers, artists and entrepreneurs who see their future in
this former industrialized Valley, are purchasing old bank and retail
buildings on Main Street, long since used for their original purposes.
Creativity, leadership, engagement
and collaboration at all levels of the community are helping the Blackstone
Valley. Groups of people are organizing to continue the community
redevelopment efforts. Two real estate investment firms, speak publicly
regularly, about the place-making work of the Tourism Council and National
Heritage Corridor that has drawn them to the Blackstone Valley. Together
they have approximately $1,000,000 in investments in the restoration of
historic properties along the Blackstone and Branch Rivers.
Other groups are organizing to
purchase and restore essential historic buildings to tell better the
national story the Blackstone Valley holds. Private investors are
participating with the non-profit and government sectors to restore former
textile buildings that have here-to-for were not feasibly restored. The
story of the Blackstone Valley is now understood by all sectors of the
community and they work together to make the Blackstone Valley a
whole-place. Today, four visitor centers are operating along the Blackstone
River Valley National Heritage Corridor to serve to tell the story of
America's Industrial Birthplace and to help visitors, residents and
potential new businesses come to learn where their next investment may be.
Samuel Slater’s Mill has been
preserved and is the centerpiece for Pawtucket riverfront and downtown main
street development. It presently operates as a museum offering working
exhibits and living history presentations. National Park Rangers traverse
the Valley to tell the story of the Birthplace of America’s Industrial
Revolution. Currently, there are now 21 species of fish living in the
Blackstone River.
The Blackstone Canal, originally
dug alongside the river in 1828, has been placed on the National Register of
Historic Places and is now a popular location for education, public
recreation and passive enjoyment. Many of the working mills and mill
villages are being restored and converted into housing or modern office
space.
In 1997, the City of Woonsocket
led the effort to preserve their history and culture of the Blackstone
Valley by developing the Museum of Work and Culture, to give tribute to the
ethnic groups and the work they performed to shape the Valley. The
Irish-American band Pendragon hosts regular performances in a renovated
theater they restored from a former Masonic Temple.
Moreover, the cities of Pawtucket and Providence have developed special arts
districts. A bicycle way that extends the length of Blackstone River is
being constructed. Presently, many cultural attractions and events draw
thousands of visitors to the National Heritage Corridor.
Since 1993, the Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council has carried over 300,000 people on its riverboat Blackstone
Valley Explorer. In 2000, a British-built canal boat, The Samuel Slater, was
imported to the Blackstone Valley to operate for river tours and serve as a
floating bed and breakfast, and a third riverboat is used to cruise sections
of the Blackstone and Providence rivers.
Events like the Rhode Island
Chinese Dragon Boat Race and Taiwan Day Festival gather different entities
such as, non-profit organizations, the City of Pawtucket, private developers
and local residents, the Rhode Island Chinese American Church, China Air,
and the Taipei Office of Culture and Economic Development of Boston, to
develop a impressive international riverfront event.
In 2005, a first-time event highlighted the historic, artistic, cultural and
environmental attributes of the Blackstone River Valley by providing a
weekend to celebrate the Preserve America designations. The Blackstone
Valley Footsteps in History Preserve America Program was the largest arts,
environmental, heritage and cultural event in the National Heritage
Corridor’s history, encompassing the 24 communities at 150 venues throughout
the Valley. This event took place through the collaborative effort of the
Blackstone Valley Tourism Council, the Blackstone Valley Chamber of
Commerce, Massachusetts Historical Commission and the Blackstone Valley
National Heritage Corridor Commission, the Rhode Island Historical
Preservation & Heritage Commission, the National Trust for Historic
Preservation and several prominent corporations expressing their social
responsibility. In 2006, these agencies were awarded a $240,000 federal
matching grant from Preserve America to continue and expand this 150-venue
event through 2006 and 2007.
Elderhostel programs, the National Trust for Historic Preservation, several
study groups from England, Brazil and different communities through out the
United States have been using the Blackstone Valley as a classroom. The
Tourism Council currently offers 10 Elderhostel programs annually. These
programs are built from the ground-up to create a laboratory-like setting
for groups of 30 to 40 people who come to learn and experience the Valley
first-hand.
Last but not least, today, several regional educational institutions, such
as Johnson & Wales University, Brown University, and University of Rhode
Island include the Blackstone as part of their curriculum (Billington &
Manheim, 2002).
These positive changes led
corporations to reflect the need to be responsible for all community
stakeholders. Local businesses started making decisions on their investments
using social and ethical principles and realizing they could be profitable
while reducing negative impacts on the community. According to Fraser
(2005), Rodwell (2006) and Dodds and Joppe (2005), the definition of
corporate social responsibility and sustainable tourism share similar
principles and elements, in that both concentrate on identifying and
engaging stakeholders and assuring forethought of how their actions impact
others. While corporate social responsibility refers to companies’
simultaneous obligation to all of its stakeholders and the search for
sustainable development, sustainable tourism development requires optimal
use of environmental resources, respect for the socio-cultural authenticity
of host communities, and economic benefits to all stakeholders (World
Tourism Organization, 2004).
In addition, there are increasing
overall societal and environmental concerns, which increase the demand for
more sustainable destinations and travel preferences. This trend is
increasing the pressure for destination management policies and corporate
responsibility. Because businesses impact lives, finances, health, and
safety of their employees, consumers, suppliers and investors, corporations
are challenged to be successful while at the same time be aware of the world
where they operate (Henderson, 2005).
Some of the private investments
that have taken place in the Valley include the following:
-
$4 million to renovate the
American Heritage River Building, Pawtucket, 1999.
-
$4 million to transform the
Green & Daniels Mills into condominiums and offices, Pawtucket.
-
$14 million to build the
Pawtucket Riverfront Lofts, condominiums and office space, Pawtucket.
-
$25 million to transform a
former textile mill into a housing complex adjacent to the Blackstone Bike
Path and River, Cumberland.
-
$1 million to develop the former
Narragansett Knitting Mills as a housing complex, Woonsocket.
-
$200 million to transform the
former Ocean State Steel Company into housing, offices and retail space,
East Providence.
-
$45 million to build riverfront
condominiums, Sutton, MA.
-
$25 million to develop three
river projects, North Smithfield (in early stages).
-
$16 million to construct a
Holiday Inn Hotel on the Pawtucket River, pending.
-
$2 million to develop
Central Falls Landing, pending.
Private investment in the
Blackstone Valley is at least today fifteen times the National Park Service
funding (Billington, 2004; Billington & Manheim, 2002).
To continue the Blackstone’s work
in imbedding sustainable tourism theory into its work, it held Rhode
Island’s first Sustainable Tourism Summit in November of 2006. It offered
presentations from world leaders in sustainable tourism. The Tourism Council
brought together its statewide policy makers and shapers to learn and
discuss how to adopt sustainable Geotourism practices statewide. The Council
hopes that the National Geographic Geotourism Charter will be signed by the
state of Rhode Island in 2007.
A TOURISM PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT LABORATORY
There is a growing need in
communities around the world to design thoughtful tourism planning and
development strategies. The concept of effective tourism planning in a
community eludes many of today's destination management organizations. In
the interest of being socially responsible, The Blackstone Valley Tourism
Council is sharing its best practices with the world, by with creating the
Sustainable Tourism Planning and Development Laboratory in the Blackstone
River Valley.
Tourism may impact a community
negatively or positively. To minimize the negative effects, it must be
planned considering many interests, including stakeholders’ participation.
The Laboratory will prepare current and future leaders with the knowledge
and skills necessary to build and shape a successful sustainable tourism
destination.
The Laboratory’s purpose is to
introduce the concept of planned sustainable tourism to local, regional,
state, provincial and worldwide tourism organization leaders and their
stakeholders.
The Laboratory is an experiential community-based learning opportunity that
offers tailor-made solutions to communities seeking to shape a tourism
development program with internationally practiced tourism planning
strategies. Each initiative is presented over a five-day period and is
designed to empower stakeholders in leading enlightened community
development.
With 20 years’ experience in
sustainable tourism planning and development in the Birthplace of America’s
Industrial Revolution, the Blackstone Valley Tourism Council collegially
shares its expertise. Led by highly skilled practitioners with extensive
experience in the private and public sectors, this program provides a
learning experience that prepares, transforms and encourages key decision
makers and shapers to contribute effectively to their communities. It is
important that businesses evolve along the continuum towards the
“sustainable vision” and managers and stakeholders are able to develop
strategies to facilitate this progression (Wade, 1999).
The Tourism Council has worked on four continents, exchanging ideas and
forming relationships that have nourished economic development. The staff
members of the Laboratory come from the United States, Argentina, Australia,
Rwanda, Canada, and Colombia.
One of the essential outcomes of
the Laboratory experience is the creation of a Tourism Development Plan to
guide its sustainable tourism efforts. Participating communities will
receive a comprehensive Tourism Development Plan, tailored to their needs,
which will lead to a successful destination. The Plan will be delivered to
the community 60 days after completion of the Laboratory sessions and will
be a blueprint for the community's future. While participants are encouraged
to attend the Tourism Laboratory in the Blackstone Valley to observe and
experience a regenerated tourism destination, a team from the Laboratory
will travel to the corresponding community if this is not possible.
The Laboratory experience is
flexible. It can be held at any time during the calendar year, based on the
needs of the community participants. To best maximize the experience, the
Laboratory encourages a group of three to eight people from one community to
attend. This balance of tourism planning theory and practical application
provides decision makers with knowledge and expertise to achieve sustainable
and demonstrable results in their communities.
Since the Tourism Laboratory is
uniquely tailored to meet the needs of the participating communities,
participants are asked to submit in-depth information about their community
two months before commencing the Laboratory experience. Only one community
at a time will participate in the Laboratory. Moreover, the fees for the
Laboratory include tuition, accommodations, meals, and transportation within
the Laboratory setting. All travel expenses to and from the Laboratory are
arranged for and paid by the participants and/or their respective
Administrations.
A typical day at the Laboratory
begins with a discussion led by a Subject Matter Expert. Sessions are
followed by field-learning experiences, which balance tourism planning
theory and practical application. Depending on the topics to be addressed,
typical afternoons at the Laboratory will reiterate the structure of the
morning session. At the end of each day, the entire group will have the
opportunity to debrief at a dinner meeting, and to converse about ideas and
lessons learned. This shared collegiality with the experts provides civic
leaders with the necessary knowledge and expertise to achieve sustainable
and demonstrable results in their communities. .
The Laboratory is accessible via
Amtrak, Logan International Airport Boston, MA (BOS), and TF Green Airport
Providence, RI (PVD). Instructional materials are mined from the World
Tourism Organization, Business Enterprises for Sustainable Travel and other
recognized best-practice tourism planning and development organizations.
CONCLUSION
This paper examines the impact of
education, leadership, involvement and social and corporate awareness upon
the regeneration of the communities in the Blackstone Valley. Sustainable
tourism planning and development has created positive change in the Valley
during several decades. Partnerships among the private and public sectors,
historic preservation, landscape enhancements, and education have stopped
the economic “free-fall” and created awareness “to endure that the
Blackstone Valley is not just a place to live but a place worth living”
(Billington & Manheim, 2002, p.358). Through the Blackstone Valley’s
efforts, business constituencies have begun to recognize the importance of
being responsible to the society where they operate, beyond their
traditional functions of encouraging wealth and profit (Billington, 2004).
The Blackstone Valley has applied
World Tourism Organization (2004) and United Nations Environmental Programme
& World Tourism Organization (2005) principles to become a sustainable
visitor destination. The Valley has preserved its environment, respected the
socio-cultural authenticity of the local communities, and provided economic
growth to all stakeholders. Leadership, creativity, collaboration,
commitment and social accountability from all parts of the community have
lead the Valley to find its direction, follow its vision and share it with
others along the way (Billington & Manheim, 2002).
The Sustainable Planning and
Development Tourism Laboratory is the next challenge for the Blackstone
Valley Tourism Council in its dedication to lead social responsibility to
the larger community. According to the Society of American Travel Writers
(1995), the Blackstone Valley is the “Phoenix rising”. The Blackstone Valley
Tourism Council accepts that commendation with the eagerness to share their
success.
Conclusions
From America’s first
industrialized and polluted landscape evolves the Sustainable Tourism
Planning and Development Laboratory, a learning initiative that prepares,
encourages and transforms key decision makers and shapers to effectively
design a sustainable vision for their respective communities. One of the
essential outcomes of the Laboratory experience is the creation of a Tourism
Development Plan to guide its sustainable tourism efforts.
Through the laboratory and other essential outreach projects, the Blackstone
Valley Tourism Council continues to serve as a catalyst for sustainable
tourism supported by community and corporate collective consciousness.
References
Billington, R. D. (1999). Building
bridges of peace, culture & prosperity through sustainable tourism. In R. W.
Blanchard and G .D. Praetzel (Ed.), Third Global Conference - International
Institute for Peace through Tourism. Regeneration of an industrial landscape
through tourism – The Blackstone River Valley of New England (p. 74). New
York: Niagara University.
Billington, R. D. (2004). Federal
leverage attracts private investment at US heritage sites: A case study.
International Journal of Heritage Studies, 10(4), 349-359.
Billington, R. D., & Manheim, P.
(2002). Tourism in Asia: Development, Marketing, and Sustainability. In K.
Chon, V. C. S Heung & K. K. F. Wong (Ed.), Fifth Biennial Conference.
Creating sustainable tourism
development - The Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor - America’s
First Industrialized Valley: the role of leadership - Creativity,
cooperation and commitment (pp. 25-33). Hong Kong: School of Hotel and
Tourism Management.
Blackstone Valley Tourism Council.
(1992). Blackstone River Valley Rhode Island: Regional comprehensive tourism
plan 1992 for the communities of Pawtucket, Cumberland, Central Falls,
Woonsocket, North Smithfield, Glocester, Burrillville, Lincoln and
Smithfield. Pawtucket, RI: Author.
Blackstone Valley National
Heritage Corridor. (2006). John H. Chafee Blackstone River Valley National
Heritage Corridor: What’s a Corridor? Retrieved February 10, 2006, from
Dodds, R., & Joppe, M. (2005,
June). CSR in the tourism industry? The status of and potential for
certification, codes of conduct and guidelines. Study prepared for the CSR
Practice Foreign Investment Advisory Service Investment Climate Department.
Fraser, B. W. (2005, February).
Corporate social responsibility. Internal Auditor. 41-47.
Henderson, H. (2005). Socially
responsible practice have business seeing green. Journal of Financial
Planning, 16.
Henderson, D. (2005). The role of
business in the world of today. Dual responsibilities of NGOs: market and
institutional responsibilities and ethics. Journal of Corporate Citizenship,
17, 30-32. London: Greenleaf Publishing.
National Geographic Society.
(2006). National Geographic Center for sustainable destinations: About
geotourism. Retrieved February 10, 2006, from
http://nationalgeographic.com/travel/sustainable/about_geotourism.html
Ritchie, J. R. B., & Crouch, G. I.
(2003). The competitive destination: A sustainable tourism perspective.
Oxon, UK: CABI Publishing.
Rodwell, R. (2006, January 21).
Social responsibility moves up the agenda companies are realizing the value
of adopting core principles following much corporate disgrace [Electronic
version]. South China Morning Post Publishers, Ltd.
Rypkema, D. D. (2006, Winter).
Economics, sustainability, and historic preservation. Forum Journal, 20(2),
27-38.
Shultz, C. (2001, April). The
Blackstone River’s industrial evolution. Yankee Magazine, 65(3), 64-79,
146-147.
Society of American Travel
Writers. (1995). Phoenix Award to Robert D. Billington: For outstanding
accomplishment in conservation and preservation.
Travel Industry Association of
America. (2006). Economic Impact of Domestic Travel on the Blackstone Valley
at Rhode Island/Massachusetts in 2004. Research Department. Washington D.C.:
Author.
United Nations Environment
Programme & World Tourism Organization. (2005). Making tourism more
sustainable: A guide for policy makers. Paris, France and Madrid, Spain:
Authors.
Wade, J. A. (1999). Students as
environmental change agents. International Journal of Contemporary
Hospitality Management, 11(5), 251-255.
World Tourism Organization.
(2001). Global code of ethics for tourism. Thirteenth WTO General Assembly:
Resolution. Santiago, Chile: Author.
World Tourism Organization.
(2004). Sustainable development of tourism: conceptual definition. Retrieved
February 10, 2006
Presented at: Business Enterprises for Sustainable Tourism
Education Network
Think Tank VI, Gerona, Spain, June 2006.
Back
to News Menu | Read
Case Study | Download PDF Format